| Platinum | The Cupcake Lady |
| Gold | Love Creamery |
| Silver | PortLand Malt Shoppe |
| Bronze | The Cozy Hen |
| Top Pick | Bridgeman's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | King of Creams |
| Top Pick | Positively 3rd St Bakery |
| Top Pick | Pretty Little Macs |
| Top Pick | Valentini's Vicino Lago |