| Platinum | Proctor Pizza & Sub Shop |
| Gold | Sammy's Pizza |
| Silver | Vintage Italian Pizza |
| Bronze | Pizza Luce |
| Top Pick | Bulldog Pizza & Grill |
| Top Pick | Duluth Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Shamrock |
| Top Pick | Thirsty Pagan Brewing |
| Top Pick | Ursa Minor Brewing |
| Top Pick | Vitta Pizza |