| Platinum | Va Bene Caffe |
| Gold | Bellisio's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Dreamland Supper Club |
| Bronze | Valentini's Vicino Lago |
| Top Pick | Alto Pino |
| Top Pick | Black Woods Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | Boat Club Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Lake Ave Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | PIckwick Restaurant & Pub |