| Platinum | Mama T's Smokin Eats |
| Gold | Love Creamery |
| Silver | The Cupcake Lady |
| Bronze | PortLand Malt Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Johnson's Lakeside Bakery & Coffee Shop |
| Top Pick | Johnsons Bakery Lincoln Park |
| Top Pick | Mamas Midnight Bakery |
| Top Pick | Positively 3rd St Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sir Benedict's Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Scoop On 47th |